Hindsight being 20/20, I unscrupulously poke and prod NHL GM's Canada Day actions. A few were applaudable, some were gambles but most made me shake my head in disbelief.
The Best
Jay Bouwmeester - Calgary Flames (5 Years - $6.68-million AVG/year)
I wouldn't want to play Flames GM Daryl Sutter in poker or chess, because he may be one of shrewdest - or at least most aggressive - tacticians in the biz. After ably handling the coaching situation, Daryl's play to move out Jordan Leopold (who was gone as a UFA anyway) and a third-round pick for just the rights to the best defenseman in the free agent crop seemed like a shot in the dark at the time, but Sutter knew.
What we didn't know, was that J-Bo would sign his big contract and forego the madness of July 1 making this the best free agent signing of 2009, filling a hole on the Flames' defensively deficent blue line corps - for what amount to mere pennies in terms of the cost to bring him in. Talk about talking care of business!
As a side note, it's amazing that an Edmonton native like Jay would sign in Calgary before free agency, seemingly foregoing a possibly higher dollar figure he could've gotten on the open market, while Calgary native Dany Heatley is kicking and screaming (and risking millions) to avoid ending up in Edmonton via trade.
Mike Knuble - Washington Capitals (2 years - $2.8-million AVG/year)
Free agency is all about filling holes for teams. Like the Flames, the Capitals filled a need for a big body to park in front of opposing nets. And they filled it big-time by bringing the rough and tumble Knuble, who can rock bodies and hammer home goals.
This is a great signing because it addresses a need at a very reasonable price.
The Decent
Daniel and Henrik Sedin - Vancouver Canucks (5 years - $6.1-million AVG/year)
This is a good deal for two point-a-game players that form the backbone of the Canucks roster. The reason it didn't make the great list is that it is over a million bucks more per year than the requested contract the twins wanted (12 years ~$5 million cap hit) and just doesn't make as much sense long term. Why GM Mike Gillis wouldn't want to sidestep having to renegotiate with these two in five years and conceivably have them retire in blue and green is beyond me.
Mattias Ohlund - Tampa Bay Lightning (7 years - $3.75-million AVG/ year)
The philosophy that Ohlund could tutor fellow swede Victor Hedman is intriguing, and if it works, could help develop the young Swede's physical play (which is the only knock against him) and help him transition to the North American game.
The cap hit is quite affordable - considering that Ohlund (who averages 25 pts/year while playing with a physcial edge) makes the same as the Blue Jackets Mike Commodore, who is barely half the player.
The cap hit is quite affordable - considering that Ohlund (who averages 25 pts/year while playing with a physcial edge) makes the same as the Blue Jackets Mike Commodore, who is barely half the player.
Like the Knuble signing, it fills a real need for the Bolts but seven years is a little long for a 32-year-old.
David Booth - Florida Panthers (6 years - $4.25-million AVG/ year)
It's a good price for Booth, who's proven he can score after 22 and 31 goal seasons. It's yet another long term deal for the Panthers (see: Horton, Weiss, Olesz, Ballard) for a core that has yet to prove a thing, ie. a playoff berth.
John Madden - Chicago Blackhawks (1 year - $2.75-million AVG/year)
A great signing for a veteran winner who could show the kids a thing or two about playing a better two-way game. The real beauty of this deal - unlike another deal the Hawks signed - is the flexability of the one year format.
Nic Antropov - Atlanta Thrashers (4 years - $4-million AVG/year)
They had to pay a small-market premium, but the Thrashers succeeded in at least finding someone who can play second (or third) fiddle to Ilya Kovalchuk down in ATL. The increased ice time could push Antropov's point total closer to 65 assuming his new found injury resistance is for real.
Mikael Samuelson - Vancover Canucks (3 years - $2.5-million AVG/year)
The Canucks made another daft signing, plucking the "hearty" swede from the Red Wings for just a modest raise. Samuelson scored some big goals during his time for the winged wheel, and the trend should continue if he finds a home with his fellow swedes- the Sedins.
Ty Conklin - St. Louis Blues (2 years - $1.3-million AVG/year)
For a team forecast to make waves, the Blues have been all but silent. What they did do made total sense if history repeats itself. Chris Mason, who had his second NHL coming-out party for the Blues (leading them to the playoffs), has a rap sheet that shows how he crashes to earth after putting up good numbers (see: Nashville). This is an insurance policy and a decent one at that.
You know, somehow, Conklin will start in the next outdoor game even though the Blues are not even in the mix for one. It's good to see Ty get a multi-year deal after several one-year contracts.
Question Marks
Craig Anderson - Colorado Avalanche (2 years - $1.8-million AVG/year)
Anderson needs to prove himself to be a legitimate number one goalie before being annointed one. Fortunately, he went to Denver where they seem to think getting solid goaltenders is all luck (and they did with Patrick Roy). Resigning undependable Peter Budaj as a backup makes this Anderson deal all the more eyebrow-raising.
Mikhail Grabovski - Toronto Maple Leafs (3 years - $2.9-million AVG/year)
A big raise for a streaky guy who's had just one good season, albeit his first at the NHL level. It's a gamble, but for a team with a gaping hole in the goal column, a reasonable one.
Jaroslav Spacek - Montreal Canadiens (3 years - $3.83-million AVG/year)
If Spacek replicates his last season with the Sabres (45 points), this deal is not just reasonable but a steal. Like with the Blues, if history repeats itself, this deal may look like a dud for the first two years of it. Spacek has produced his best seasons in contract years, most recently in Buffalo, and he seems to slump in secured years. The Habs are obviously betting on Jaro breaking the habit.
Mike Cammalleri - Montreal Canadiens (5 years - $6-million AVG/year)
After a career year of 39 goals, Cammy deserved a significant raise. He got it, but like most players who break out, you can expect the former Flame and King to score closer to 30 goals on a depleted Habs squad that may struggle next season because of lack of chemistry. This contract won't burn the Habs, but it may be a little high for the small forward who, like the recently departed Alex Tanguay, seems to excel only when playing with more prominent players.
Brian Gionta - Montreal Canadiens (5 years - $5-million AVG/year)
Unlike Cammalleri, Gionta did NOT earn a raise last season. With his goal totals tumbling the last three seasons, the miniscule forward was reduced to a smaller role on the Devils last year, and his play showed it. He should bounce back this season with the change in scenery, but apparently, the Habs may be on the list of teams that need to overpay for free agents because it isn't the most desirable locale anymore. The local media just might have something to do with that.
Mike Komisarek - Toronto Maple Leafs (5 years - $4.5-million AVG/year)
This is Robyn Regehr money for a defenseman who clearly isn't Robyn Regehr. He will have a better year for the buds, but he is being overpaid.
The Worst
Marian Hossa - Chicago Blackhawks (12 years - $5.23-million AVG/year)
Hossa clearly wants to win by taking much, much less than he could've gotten. The problem with this deal, like their contract for Brian Campbell, is way too fricken long! 12 years is fine for a team with not much going for it (or Detroit), but not for a team that has two impending RFA's next season who will be in line for astronomical raises. GM Dale Tallon has shown himself to be a smooth operator, but next offseason may just prove to be too much for him to handle.
Marian Gaborik - New York Rangers (5 years - $7.5-million AVG/year)
The requirements for a raise in the NHL are different than any other workplace in the world: in New York especially! Gaborik hasn't played a full season in the past three and while he shows flashes of brilliance (last season with 83 points) his groin issues overshadow them completely. That's two possible total dud deals (including Wade Redden's mammoth contract) GM Glen Sather has signed. How long can the blueshirts keep this guy around!? Why not bring back Mike Keenan too!?
Martin Havlat - Minnesota Wild (6 years - $5-million AVG/year)
The lesser of these three evils, the Wild have essentially replaced the more explosive and more injury-prone Gaborik for the less-explosive and less injury-prone Havlat for less cash. It's the opposite of progress and could be called downsizing. If Havlat stays healthy this deal gives Minny something it hasn't ever had - a consistent scorer. However, like Spacek, he's developing into a player only at his best in contract years - and at the end of this deal he'll be 34 which makes the breakout less likely.